Overall had a great stay at in Unit 25! Cannot beat the location and private beach area. We loved being steps from the ocean where the sandy beach area was really nice with more than enough beach chairs and places to sit. Pool area was good too and the condo property is very well maintained.
The unit itself was clean but could use some updating (bedding, decor, etc). The screen door was broken when we stayed but said it was getting fixed, and we wished there were some additional amenities like full size hand soap, small speaker, a cooler (we got one and left it for the next renters!), but you don't spend too much time in the room so it served it's purpose of relaxing, sleep, and kitchen area.
Check in/check out was easy, property managers were responsive to questions and requests like getting fresh towels after staying a couple days.
Would stay at Continental Inn and Key Colony again in a heartbeat - I feel like it's a hidden gem that I don't want too many people to find out about :)