My husband, son and I stayed at Wally's cabin for a brief weekend away after picking our son up from summer camp. It was a cute little place away. Beds and furniture were comfortable. Little touches around the cabin (coffee grounds and sweetners, toiletries, plenty of paper products, night lights, toddler plates/bowls, booklet with restaurants and info about the town, etc) - that made it special. The owners were also very responsive and great about communication.
While the cabin could admittedly use some updating, the AC could be stronger, and the cabin is a bit far to walk the boats down to the dock (throw in bed of truck or lash to roof and non-issue) - it was an overall nice time away and you can tell the owners really put effort into the cabin and care about their properties (they have the 2 next door as well).