We had been looking for a place to stay when our daughter had an interview at the Edinburgh University. This was the closest for a reasonable price at the time. In general it is a nice place to stay, comfortable and clean. A commute to Edinburgh takes about 30 mins. We also went to Falkirk, about 1hr drive which was also a quite easy trip. Disadvantages: a halfbroken iron, the lack of washing machine and a double bed in one of the bedrooms when we put our boys, 15 and 9, together.
But otherwise we would recommend it as a really nice place to stay within a reasonable distance from Edinburgh and for more than a reasonable price.